Donatello’s Restaurant
About
Pizza
Price Range : Under $10 ($)
Location
Adress: 466 3rd St, Niagara Falls, NY 14301
Phone: (716) 282-2069
Work Hours
Business info
- turned_in_notHealth Score89 out of 100
- list_altTakes ReservationsNo
- directions_carDeliveryYes
- move_to_inboxTake-outYes
- credit_cardAccepts Credit CardsYes
- thumb_upGood ForLunch, Dinner
- local_parkingParkingStreet
- directions_bikeBike ParkingYes
- accessibilityGood for KidsYes
- groupGood for GroupsYes
- insert_emoticonAmbienceCasual
- volume_upNoise LevelAverage
- local_barAlcoholNo
- transit_enterexitOutdoor SeatingNo
- wifiWi-FiNo
- tvHas TVYes
- turned_in_notWaiter ServiceNo
- fastfoodCatersYes
Reviews
-
Jimmy M.
Master Splinter would be so proud! This place is has some real good food and guess what????? It's not expensive!!! The pepperoni pizza was outstanding!!!
If you are nearby, you better stop here and get a slice or better yet.......get a pie!!!
The staff here are great, very friendly and welcoming!!!!
Great Job...Good Way to go!!! -
Benedict A.
We ordered delivery from this place after being thoroughly soaked in mansoon like rains (we're from sunny southern cali) walking back from Niagara Falls to our hotel, about 1 mile walk. Being drenched and not wanting to go back out in inclement weather, we decided to order delivery to our hotel.
I see why New Yorkers have that reputation of being rude. Guy on the phone was rough and short. Glad I looked in advance as to what to order. Almost thought he was going to start yelling at me for not knowing what to order.
I placed an order for 3 personal size pizzas. Their white sauce, italian and all meat pizza, as well as a side order of 10 honey garlic glazed wings. They gave me an estimate of 45 min, and they were right on the dot with the 45 min delivery. Pricing was expensive. With delivery, tax and tip, it came out to more than $45.
So with great expectation, I dove into the slices of New York pizza!!! And it was a dud, borderline disappointing. It was just so average.... flavors were minimal. Wish they had some kind of cheese or peppers to add on it. My most favorite was the all meat then white sauce and least of all the italian. I do like the thin crust New York is known for. It was crisp and flaky in a good way and not doughy at all.
Their saving grace is their wings. Copious amounts of honey sauce. Wings were as drenched as I was in the sauce, but they still maintained the crunchy exterior. And the interior of the wing was juicy and oh so good. Maybe they should become a wing place instead... havent totally ruled out eating new york pizza, but this place didn't make me too excited to try it again. -
Jimmy L.
This little pizza place is a hidden gem. Needed a place to stop in Niagara Falls, for a unplanned visit. This pizza revived me and my friend back to life. The buffalo chicken pizza was spectacular and perfect ratio of chicken to cheese. Thank you, Donatello.
-
Karie D.
Great pizza and awesome service too. Guy at the front was great, blunt but funny. The pizza is authentic and while visiting the falls it is great to eat local. Just a few blocks from the falls and the street parking wasn't bad either. Will visit again if ever back in NY.
-
Aron T.
Great fresh food! Anytime I'm working in downtown NF I order me up some nice Donatello's! There Rachel (shown in photo) is the BOMB!! They should name it the Shawn for as many times I've had it! Thanks to beyond who works there to make this food consistent, fresh, and always yummy!!